Why the Zuck are you building a Social Network?

We were promised a social network, but got social media instead. So we're building the real thing, at human scale.

I'm a child of the internet.

I still remember when 256 kbps was blazing fast. The internet then felt less like a place, and more like a portal. Every webpage you visited was the direct labor of love of some geek, and every part of it reflected their personality.

It felt like you'd been invited into the living room of a friend you'd only just met. It felt vast and intimate at the same time.

A welcoming open doorway, plants, and a cat.

The internet is vastly bigger today, a million times more capable, but also less weird. There's a certain slick sameness to the web that I can't quite put my finger on. But it's there, isn't it?

In the late '90s and early 2000s, there was just as much mania about the internet as there is about AI right now. The possibilities seemed endless (just as they do now). No one really knew what exactly the internet would become, and more importantly, no one knew what a world with something as fundamentally new as the internet would look like.

Some 25 years later, I'm kinda disappointed to report that the weird portal of infinite potential that taught me so much has become... this.

I'm not going to bore you with what's good or bad about the internet, or preach to you about dopamine fasting. Whether it's been a net positive or negative is for you to decide. I will say this though: I got two things wrong, and in both cases I vastly underestimated.

First, I underestimated how much social media would come to dominate the shape and feel of the internet. We say internet, but often we mean Instagram or TikTok or Twitter. When I first got my Facebook account, I didn't think this would be where everyone would spend most of their time online, much less most of their waking hours.

If you ask me, the simple reason is that while Facebook claimed to be a Social Network, they realized before we did that the real business was Social Media, and the advertising that comes with it. The emphasis here is on the media part, where they keep you watching, like the trash television of the '90s. The social network they promised never really got built. That should give you a hint as to why we're building one now.

But more importantly, I underestimated how much control we had over what the internet would become. I thought the internet was something that happened to me, rather than something I could make happen.

I see the same helplessness today with AI, and I want to tell you: it's not the end of the world.

With the internet behind us, we know how this playbook goes. Today everyone's launching personal AI assistants and free chatbots to get you hooked. They will use large sums of capital to grow at scale. They will then, once again, use your own data to sell you things. Except this time, they'll know exactly what you think, because you'll willingly tell their AI companions. And the seller is not some annoying banner, or unskippable video ad. It is the very smart, very convincing, very persuasive AI companion you trusted with your deepest thoughts.

So while the social media companies are busy making AI assistants, a few of us figured it was time to sneak in behind them and do the thing they said they'd do for us: make a real social network, not social media. Not AT SCALE, but to human scale.

A cat sleeping in an armchair beside books and a sunlit window.

As the Counting Crows cawed right around the time the dot-com bubble burst:

Don't it always seem to go
That you don't know what you've got 'til it's gone?
They paved paradise, put up a parking lot

With innernet, we hope to build that living room again, for you and your friends. We hope you find the AI-first internet a wonderful and weird and endearing, just like I once did. And we hope we don't turn it into a parking lot or a dumpster fire, again.